Connect with us

Technology News

It’s her decision vs Can’t stop heartbeat: SC divided on ending 26-week pregnancy | India News

Published

on


TWO DAYS after it allowed a married woman to medically terminate her 26-week pregnancy, a two-judge all-woman bench of the Supreme Court Wednesday disagreed on giving the go-ahead for the procedure and referred her plea to the Chief Justice of India to be considered by an appropriate bench of larger strength.

While Justice B V Nagarathna said the petitioner’s “decision” not to continue with the pregnancy “must be respected”, Justice Hima Kohli said “my judicial conscience does not permit” acceding to her request.

What changed Justice Kohli’s mind was an email from an AIIMS doctor, seeking clarification on the Supreme Court’s October 9 order permitting the woman to undergo MTP (medical termination of pregnancy) and asking her to appear before the AIIMS authorities for the procedure.

“Having regard to the information obtained in the email… I am not inclined to permit the petitioner to terminate the pregnancy,” Justice Kohli said.
Differing with this, Justice Nagarathna said the October 9 order was a “well considered” one and “having regard to the concrete determination made by the petitioner, I find that her decision must be respected. The court is here not to substitute its decision for the decision of the petitioner”.

The woman, a mother of two, had approached the court stating that she was suffering from lactational amenorrhea and depression and was, therefore, unwilling to continue with the pregnancy.

Festive offer

The communication dated October 10, which was addressed by the doctor to Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati who represented the Centre in the matter, said the foetus appeared to be “viable” indicating a “strong possibility of survival”.

The doctor said that in light of the situation, “we will need a directive from the Supreme Court on whether a foeticide (stopping the foetal heart) can be done before termination”. The communication pointed out that doctors “perform this procedure (foeticide) for a foetus which has abnormal development, but generally not done in a normal foetus”.

Explained

The right, the limit

All women in the country, regardless of marital status, can end pregnancy up to 24 weeks. In September 2022, the Supreme Court extended the right to safe and legal abortion up to 24 weeks of pregnancy to unmarried and single women.

Following the email, Bhati moved the court of CJI D Y Chandrachud Tuesday evening itself. The CJI asked the Centre to file a formal application for recall of the October 9 order and asked AIIMS to put it on hold until the application was heard Wednesday by the bench of Justices Nagarathna and Kohli.

Hearing the matter, Justice Kohli took serious exception to AIIMS authorities seeking clarification by citing fresh concerns, and asked why the concerns were not conveyed to the court earlier when it had sought a medical opinion on the woman’s request for MTP permission.

Justice Nagarathna also conveyed her displeasure over the Centre approaching the CJI’s bench against its order and said, “If a private party does that, there will be breakdown of the system of this court. We are concerned and disturbed about this,” she said.

“Tell us, when this court decides a matter, without any pleading whatsoever, how can you move an intra-court appeal before a three-judge bench of this court and then interfere with the order of this court? We do not appreciate this. If the Union of India starts doing this, tomorrow a private party will also start doing it. We are an integral court. Every bench of the Supreme Court is the Supreme Court. We are one court sitting in separate benches. Speaking for myself, I don’t appreciate this on the part of the Union of India. You could have only asked for the constitution of a bench after filing pleadings. Even in the absence of a pleading, you have moved the Hon’ble Chief Justice. How is it possible?” she said.

Bhati said that upon receipt of the AIIMS letter seeking clarification, she tried to approach Justice Kohli, who was sitting in a different bench combination, but was asked to approach the CJI, because it is only the CJI who can reconstitute the special bench to hear a recall application.
At this, Justice Nagarathna said, “That is one thing. But in the absence of a pleading, how can you go and disturb the court of the Hon’ble Chief Justice and seek an intervention?”

To the bench’s query on why the government could not have waited for one more day, Bhati said, “Since the court’s direction was to carry out the termination yesterday only, I had to mention (the matter).”

Conveying her displeasure over the email, Justice Kohli said, “What’s being said now… is entirely much wider. This is not what was being said (earlier). If they wanted, they could have done all of that then, and the court would have taken notice of it because we are relying on the report… We ourselves asked for it… How is it that they decided to go this way only after the order was passed and not earlier?”

Bhati said, “These questions had arisen in our minds during the hearing of the matter.”

Justice Kohli said, “That is you as an individual. We are laypersons… Why do we rely on the medical report? Because we don’t know and they know better. And we are relying on a report because there is a whole team that is part of that interaction with the patient… After giving us an ambiguous report and saying yes, the lady does have that problem, it could go up, the mental issues and she could have then postpartum also, to say now… And which court will, pray, say stop a heartbeat of a foetus which has a life? We are wondering! Which court would do that? Speaking for myself, I wouldn’t. So why weren’t they not so candid we are very curious to know. Why were they hedging?”

“Now to say there is a strong possibility of survival and that we will stop the heartbeat if the court says. For heaven’s sake, which court will stop the foetal heartbeat? If this was the stand they had to take, they should have said all of it at that point in time, that though there is a financial, physical, mental, emotional thing on the lady, if you keep the child a bit longer, and we persuade her, the option of adoption could have been considered. Because if you remember, the parents did say that if we have no option, we will like to continue with the pregnancy and retain the child with us,” Justice Kohli said.

Bhati said “they were extensively counselled” and “in all fairness, she (the woman seeking permission for MTP) was a little undecided”.
The bench also interacted with the woman and her husband in light of the new medical opinion.

As the woman insisted that she did not want to have the child, Justice Kohli tried to explain that keeping the foetus for a few more weeks would improve the chances of it being born healthy, failing which there was a risk of it being born alive with physical and mental disabilities.

However, the woman said that she did not want to postpone the MTP.

Most Read

1
Horoscope, October 12, 2023: Check astrological prediction for Scorpio, Aries and other signs
2
Bengaluru: Traffic congestion witnesses a dip at KR Puram Junction after commencement of full operations on Metro Purple Line

The bench then asked her to submit an affidavit making clear what she wants. She accordingly furnished the affidavit stating “I have made a wilful and conscious decision to medically terminate my pregnancy and don’t want to keep the baby even if it survives”.

In the order, Justices Nagarathna and Kohli recorded their respective displeasure with the Centre and the email communication.

Justice Nagarathna also wrote, “This is not a case where the question of viable baby being born or unborn is to be really considered when the interest of the petitioner has to be given more balanced width and reference the socio-economic situation in which the petitioner is placed, the fact that she already has two children, the second child being only one year of age and the fact that she has reiterated that her mental condition, and the medicines she is taking for a mental condition, do not permit her to continue with the pregnancy.”





Source link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Technology News

Circle to Search: Share part of your screen!

Published

on

By

According to recent reports, Circle to Search, a feature introduced with the Samsung Galaxy S24 series in January 2024, might soon undergo an upgrade. Initially allowing users to copy text from selected areas, it’s now rumored to include the capability to capture and share screenshots of specific screen sections.

This enhanced functionality, observed in the latest version of Circle to Search, enables users to not only copy text but also capture and share screen images. A video shared by a tipster on X showcased this update, revealing new options of Copy and Share upon selecting an area. Even adjustments to the selected region don’t remove these options, ensuring a seamless experience. Users can either copy the image to the clipboard for further editing or share it directly through various apps.

Previously, the visual lookup feature solely facilitated text copying. While Android devices offer a three-finger swipe-down gesture for quick screenshots, it captures the entire screen, necessitating subsequent cropping. This new functionality streamlines the process, allowing users to select and share specific screen sections in just two steps.

Interestingly, Google recently addressed concerns about accidental activations of Circle to Search in a podcast featuring its developers. They acknowledged the issue and assured users of an impending fix. This indicates ongoing efforts to refine the feature for a smoother user experience.

Continue Reading

Technology News

Discounted OnePlus Nord CE 3 price in India: Check it out!

Published

on

By

The OnePlus Nord CE 3 has recently undergone another price reduction in India, marking a significant update for potential buyers. Initially introduced to the Indian market in June 2023, this smartphone received its first price adjustment in November of the same year. The base variant, featuring 8GB of RAM and 128GB of internal storage, was notably listed at a price Rs. 2,000 lower than its launch price, signaling OnePlus’s commitment to providing competitive pricing to its customers.

The OnePlus Nord CE 3 is powered by an octa-core Qualcomm Snapdragon chipset and ships with the Android 13-based operating system. It boasts a triple rear camera setup, enhancing its photography capabilities, and supports SuperVOOC charging, ensuring rapid replenishment of its battery. The inclusion of these features positions the Nord CE 3 as a compelling option for smartphone enthusiasts seeking a balance between performance, affordability, and innovation.

The recent unveiling of the OnePlus Nord CE 4 in India marks the continuation of OnePlus’s commitment to delivering cutting-edge technology to its users. Serving as the successor to the Nord CE 3, the Nord CE 4 is expected to build upon the strengths of its predecessor while introducing new enhancements and features to further elevate the user experience.

When considering the revised pricing of the OnePlus Nord CE 3, it’s evident that OnePlus aims to make its devices more accessible to a wider audience. The reduction in price, particularly on platforms like Amazon and the OnePlus India website, presents an opportunity for consumers to acquire a high-quality smartphone at a more affordable rate.

Let’s delve deeper into the specifications and features of the OnePlus Nord CE 3 to understand its capabilities and appeal to potential buyers.

OnePlus Nord CE 3 Price in India (Revised)

The base variant of the OnePlus Nord CE 3, featuring 8GB of RAM and 128GB of internal storage, was initially launched in India at Rs. 26,999. Following its first price cut in November, the price was reduced to Rs. 24,999. Now, the same variant is available on Amazon at Rs. 22,990, representing a Rs. 2,009 reduction from its previous price. Furthermore, customers can benefit from an additional flat Rs. 2,000 instant discount on ICICI and HDFC Bank cards, bringing the effective price down to Rs. 20,990.

On the OnePlus India website, the 8GB + 128GB variant is priced at Rs. 22,999, marking a Rs. 2,000 decrease from the November price of Rs. 24,999. It is worth noting that this discount is exclusively applicable to the 128GB model, as the higher-end 256GB variant is currently listed as out of stock.

OnePlus Nord CE 3 Specifications and Features

Display:

The OnePlus Nord CE 3 boasts a 6.7-inch full-HD+ fluid AMOLED display with a resolution of 1,080 x 2,412 pixels. With a refresh rate of up to 120Hz, users can enjoy smooth and fluid visuals, enhancing their overall viewing experience.

Processor and Performance:

Powered by the Qualcomm Snapdragon 782G SoC, the OnePlus Nord CE 3 delivers robust performance and efficient multitasking capabilities. With up to 12GB of RAM and up to 256GB of onboard storage, users can seamlessly navigate between apps and store their multimedia content with ease.

Operating System:

The smartphone ships with Android 13-based OxygenOS 13.1, providing users with a clean and intuitive user interface coupled with a plethora of customization options. OxygenOS is known for its smooth performance and timely software updates, ensuring that users stay up-to-date with the latest features and security patches.

Camera:

The OnePlus Nord CE 3 features a versatile camera setup, comprising a 50-megapixel primary sensor with optical image stabilization (OIS) and electronic image stabilization (EIS) support. Accompanying this primary sensor is an 8-megapixel sensor with an ultra-wide-angle lens and a 2-megapixel macro shooter, allowing users to capture a wide range of subjects with stunning detail and clarity. On the front, the device houses a 16-megapixel sensor for high-quality selfies and video calls.

Battery and Charging:

Equipped with a robust 5,000mAh battery, the OnePlus Nord CE 3 offers ample battery life to power through a full day of usage. Additionally, the device supports 80W wired SuperVOOC charging, enabling users to quickly replenish the battery and minimize downtime.

Connectivity:

The OnePlus Nord CE 3 supports a comprehensive range of connectivity options, including 5G, 4G LTE, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth 5.2, NFC, GPS, and USB Type-C. Whether it’s streaming multimedia content, browsing the web, or staying connected with friends and family, users can rely on the Nord CE 3 to deliver seamless connectivity and performance.

Security:

For enhanced security, the OnePlus Nord CE 3 features an in-display fingerprint sensor, allowing users to conveniently unlock their device with a simple touch. This biometric authentication method adds an extra layer of protection to safeguard sensitive data and personal information.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the OnePlus Nord CE 3 offers a compelling combination of performance, affordability, and innovation, making it an attractive choice for smartphone enthusiasts in India. With its recent price reduction and competitive specifications, the Nord CE 3 presents a compelling value proposition for consumers seeking a high-quality smartphone experience without breaking the bank. As OnePlus continues to innovate and introduce new features with each iteration, the Nord CE 3 stands as a testament to the company’s commitment to delivering exceptional devices tailored to the needs of its users.

Continue Reading

Technology News

Namma Yatri launches cab service in Bengaluru

Published

on

By

In its largest market, Bengaluru, ride-hailing company Namma Yatri has expanded its services to include cab-hailing, marking a significant shift from its previous focus on auto rickshaws. Namma Yatri, known for pioneering a daily subscription model as opposed to the commission-based model utilized by competitors like Ola and Uber, had initially concentrated on auto rickshaws in Bengaluru. However, it now features a distinct section on its app dedicated to booking cabs in the city. Additionally, Namma Yatri already provides cab rides in Kochi and Kolkata.

The decision to venture into cab services follows Namma Yatri’s separation from its former parent company, Justpay, and comes on the heels of a reported expansion plan announced on April 1st. The move also aligns with the broader trend observed in the industry, as both Ola and Uber have recently introduced subscription-based plans for auto-rickshaw drivers on their platforms. This strategic shift towards subscription-based models, akin to Namma Yatri’s approach, as well as that of Rapido, highlights a growing preference within the industry for alternative pricing structures beyond traditional booking fees or commissions.

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2017 Zox News Theme. Theme by MVP Themes, powered by WordPress.